Gaines Street Pies

Gaines Street Pies hums with the energy of Tallahassee’s college core, serving up cheeky, comic-themed pies to a crowd that’s equal parts students and locals in the know. The walls pulse with pop-culture nods—Marvel fans especially will feel at home—and there’s always a steady rhythm of friends catching up over slices and craft beers. This isn’t your buttoned-up Neapolitan joint; it’s a relaxed spot where inventive flavor combos (think jalapeño poppers wrapped in bacon as a sidekick to your pizza) rule the menu, and everything is made fresh—no freezers hiding in the back. Portions are generous, salads are unexpectedly crisp with house-made dressings, and the staff keep things lighthearted even when the place is buzzing. It’s an anchor for late-night cravings or casual gatherings, bridging Tallahassee’s town-and-gown divide and providing a reliable backdrop for both lifelong locals and those just passing through the FSU orbit.