Broken Tree Taproom & Pizza of Appleton

Nestled along the banks of the Fox River, Broken Tree Taproom & Pizza of Appleton is one of those rare finds that feels both familiar and quietly surprising—a place where the scent of wood-fired dough mingles with a cool river breeze. The taproom draws an eclectic crowd: cyclists coasting in off the trail, families savoring a riverside meal, transplants from New York searching for a taste that might just live up to their childhood memories. The heart of Broken Tree is its pizza—crisp, blistered crusts that crunch under your teeth, layered with fresh, thoughtfully chosen ingredients. The Fun Guy emerges as a local legend, but even classics like the Margherita are handled with the kind of care you’d expect from proud artisans rather than short-order cooks. The space itself feels open yet cozy—a sun-drenched patio runs right up to the water’s edge, making it an obvious gathering point on warm afternoons. Inside, the energy hums with friendly staff who remember faces and seem genuinely happy to share their favorites from the tap. Beer takes center stage here: dozens of craft selections flow alongside ciders and a handful of wines for those seeking something different. Prices aren’t shy, especially on drinks, but there’s an unspoken understanding that quality is worth lingering over. What stands out most is how Broken Tree bridges communities. Locals know about the resident discount (if you dine in), while newcomers are welcomed without pretense. It’s a pause button in Appleton’s rhythm—a place where tradition collides gently with modern craft culture, and where people arrive as strangers but may leave planning their next visit before they’ve finished their last slice.