Tellers: An American Chophouse
Known For
- •USDA Prime dry-aged steaks
- •Duck fat French fries
- •Colossal pastrami sandwich
- •Raspberry cream pie
- •Apple pecan salad
Insider Tips
Best Time
Weekday lunches for value Power Lunch or evenings for celebratory dinners
Ideal For
Pro Tip
Request a table near the original Mosler vault for the most atmospheric dining experience.
Editorial Review
Step through the grand doors of Tellers and you’re greeted by the stately bones of a bygone bank—think soaring 30-foot windows, vault-turned-wine cellar, and a copper bar that glows under the amber lights. This isn’t your average steakhouse: it’s where old money meets modern taste, with USDA Prime steaks dry-aged to perfection, duck fat fries that make grown adults swoon, and a raspberry cream pie worth plotting your return for. Locals treat Tellers as the go-to spot for anniversaries or power lunches, while out-of-towners seek it out as a pilgrimage for classic American chophouse fare with refined flair. There’s a sense of occasion here—a place where families gather for milestone dinners, business deals are inked over Bordeaux, and the staff remembers your favorite cut. In a town that prizes tradition, Tellers bridges Islip’s past with a cosmopolitan edge, serving as both a community anchor and a culinary ambassador for Long Island.
Price Level
$$$$
Website
tellerschophouse.comContact
+1 631-277-7070
Outdoor Seating
Reservations Available
Hours
- Sunday: 12PM - 9PM
- Monday: 12PM - 10PM
- Tuesday: 12PM - 10PM
- Wednesday: 12PM - 10PM
- Thursday: 12PM - 10PM
- Friday: 12PM - 11PM
- Saturday: 12PM - 11PM
Frontier Insights
Major destination with tourist appeal
TripAdvisor: Top 10% (#1 of 50)
Popular With
Tourist Awareness
TripAdvisor: #1 of 50 Places to Eat in Islip
- Outdoor seating available
- Reservations accepted
Turn 30-Second Visits Into 15-Minute Trip Planning
Drifter AI transforms your site visitors into travelers to your destination. Built specifically for DMOs, not generic travel software.
Prove Your Worth
Track engagement and partner referrals to show stakeholders exactly how your website drives tourism
Support Partners
Monitor clicks to hotels, restaurants, and attractions - prove your value to local businesses
No IT Needed
One line of code works with Simpleview, WordPress, or any website platform