East Meadow, Long Island, New York

Pietro's of East Meadow

Dining
4.6(759)

Known For

  • Sesame-crusted pizza
  • Garlic knots with vodka (drunken) sauce
  • Sticky toffee cake
  • Banana cheesecake
  • Pistachio ricotta cake

Insider Tips

Best Time

Weeknights for quieter atmosphere; outdoor igloos best reserved in advance during cooler months.

Ideal For

Family dinnersDate nightsCelebratory gatheringsSmall group outings

Pro Tip

Book one of the outdoor igloos for a private, cozy dining experience—perfect for intimate conversations.

Editorial Review

Step into Pietro's of East Meadow and you’re greeted by the comforting hum of a neighborhood institution that’s worn its roots proudly since 1976. The air carries the warmth of brick walls draped with leafy flourishes, a blend of old-school Long Island coziness and playful modern touches. On chilly nights, the outdoor igloos become coveted sanctuaries—private bubbles where laughter and heart-to-hearts flow without interruption. Inside, attentive servers breeze through the snug dining room, offering menu guidance with genuine enthusiasm. Locals flock here for multi-generational gatherings, couples claim quiet corners for date night, and newcomers discover why the sesame-crusted pizza and pillowy garlic knots have earned a cult following. There’s nothing generic about Pietro’s—this is where tradition mingles with creativity, and every meal feels like a celebration of community ties both old and new. Whether you’re savoring their famed vodka (or “drunken”) sauce or splitting a sticky toffee cake, Pietro’s remains an anchor for East Meadow—a place where family, food, and neighborhood stories are always on the menu.

Price Level

$$

Contact

+1 516-794-8820

Outdoor Seating

Reservations Available

Hours

  • Sunday: 12PM - 9:30PM
  • Monday: 4PM - 9:30PM
  • Tuesday: 4PM - 9:30PM
  • Wednesday: 4PM - 9:30PM
  • Thursday: 4PM - 9:30PM
  • Friday: 12PM - 10PM
  • Saturday: 12PM - 10PM

Frontier Insights

Excellent quality, understated presence

Only 759 reviews but 4.6 stars

Popular With

FamiliesCouplesSolo Travelers

Tourist Awareness

LevelHigh

TripAdvisor: #9 of 131 Places to Eat in East Meadow

  • Outdoor seating available
  • Reservations accepted
Data confidence: high(5 sources)
For Destination Marketing Organizations

Turn 30-Second Visits Into 15-Minute Trip Planning

Drifter AI transforms your site visitors into travelers to your destination. Built specifically for DMOs, not generic travel software.

Prove Your Worth

Track engagement and partner referrals to show stakeholders exactly how your website drives tourism

Support Partners

Monitor clicks to hotels, restaurants, and attractions - prove your value to local businesses

No IT Needed

One line of code works with Simpleview, WordPress, or any website platform

Annual budgets welcomeReal-time updatesDedicated support