Lumberjack Johnny's Axe Throwing & Pinball

Step through the doors of Lumberjack Johnny's and you’re greeted by a riot of clattering pinball bumpers, the satisfying thunk of axes meeting wood, and the easy-going hospitality that feels like a Wisconsin handshake. This isn’t your average bar or arcade—it's part neighborhood hangout, part adrenaline playground, and entirely unpretentious. The open layout invites you to roam from beautifully maintained pinball machines, each one gleaming with care, to spacious axe-throwing lanes where everyone from first-timers to seasoned throwers gets a chance to let loose. Locals come here not just for the games but for the sense of camaraderie. Staff float between groups, offering pointers whether you’re sinking another bullseye or just trying not to bounce an axe off the floor. There’s zero judgment—just encouragement and a genuine desire to see folks leave grinning. The menu surprises with quality and variety; plates arrive fresh and flavorful, more ambitious than you'd expect from a place built around play. Beer lovers find plenty to love too: over 100 craft options line the fridges, spotlighting regional breweries alongside well-loved classics. The vibe is welcoming for all ages—a rare feat—and newcomers regularly discover themselves chatting with regulars over flipper scores or local IPA recommendations. While it could get rowdy on peak nights, there’s always an undercurrent of good-natured fun rather than chaos. This is where Appleton’s social fabric gets stitched together: birthday parties, date nights, family competitions, and spontaneous celebrations all share the same laughter-filled space. It’s a place where tradition gets remixed—where old-school pinball nostalgia meets new-school axe-slinging bravado—and everyone leaves a little lighter than when they arrived.