Legendairy Cookies 'N Creamery

Legendairy Cookies 'N Creamery sits right on the busy College Avenue stretch in downtown Appleton, anchoring itself as a beacon for anyone with a sweet tooth and a sense of adventure. The shop’s name hints at its playful spirit, and inside, the vibe is both easygoing and energetic—a haven for families ducking in after dinner, college students on a sugar-fueled study break, and locals introducing out-of-towners to Appleton’s quirkiest desserts. There’s nothing generic here: the star offerings are decadent ice cream sandwiches that fuse rich scoops between hunks of homemade cookies and brownies. These aren’t your average cookie sandwiches; there’s an almost celebratory excess to them—giant in size, unapologetically messy, and meant for sharing or savoring solo if you’re feeling bold. The gingerbread man sandwich is a local legend, while classics like the Cookie Monster lure those who want to relive childhood glee. Every bite is soft and chewy, contrasting beautifully with creamy cold ice cream. The grab-and-go fridge is a clever addition for those dashing in for a quick fix or hoping to take the magic home. Service is friendly, personal, and informed—staff don’t just scoop; they guide you through the menu’s quirks and even offer samples with genuine warmth. Sometimes there’s a wait when business booms or staffing is lean, but regulars treat it like part of the ritual. Prices can feel steep compared to chain dessert shops nearby, yet portion sizes more than justify the splurge. Legendairy isn’t just another dessert stop—it’s woven into Appleton’s rhythm. Whether you’re swapping stories over sweets after a show at the PAC or treating your nephew instead of bringing cake to his wedding, it’s become a gathering spot that bridges generations and brings people together through pure indulgence.