Alley Cat Coffeehouse

Step off Main Street and into Alley Cat Coffeehouse, where a century-old bank vault stands guard over the aroma of fresh espresso. The exposed brick and quirky cat motifs signal you’re in a space that’s both playful and fiercely local. It’s the kind of spot where regulars know the baristas by name, and newcomers are greeted like old friends. The horchata latte is unexpectedly bold, served alongside a lineup of breakfast bagels that don’t shy away from flavor or dietary inclusivity—think gluten-free, dairy-free, and sugar-free options without pretense. Sunlight streams through tall windows onto mismatched tables, inviting laptop warriors and families alike to linger. Alley Cat isn’t just a caffeine stop; it anchors Hortonville’s small-town rhythm, balancing Madison-style eclecticism with Midwest warmth. Locals come for the familiar faces and the chance to support their own; travelers find an authentic slice of Wisconsin community, unfiltered and unapologetically genuine.