Amagansett, East Hampton, New York

434 on Main

Stay
4.8(46)

Known For

  • Homemade frittatas
  • Fresh fruit platters
  • Waffles
  • Beach gear (passes, towels, chairs, umbrellas)

Insider Tips

Best Time

Spring through early fall for beach access and vibrant village life

Ideal For

Couple getawaysSpecial occasionsDog-friendly staysRemote work escapes

Pro Tip

If you need to work remotely, ask to use the dining room table before check-in—hosts are happy to accommodate.

Editorial Review

434 on Main isn’t just a bed and breakfast—it’s a soulful retreat nestled in the heart of Amagansett. Step inside and the warm hospitality from Victor and Cam instantly sets the tone; there’s a sense of genuine welcome that feels more like staying with longtime friends than a standard inn. Rooms are airy, immaculate, and peaceful, with thoughtful touches that reveal a deep care for both comfort and style. Mornings here begin with inventive, home-cooked breakfasts—think fluffy frittatas, fresh fruit, and homemade pastries—crafted to accommodate every guest’s needs. The inn’s location hits a sweet spot: a stroll from Amagansett’s independent shops and laid-back eateries, and close enough to the beach that a sun-drenched walk is never out of reach. 434 on Main also bridges communities, drawing city escapees and East End locals alike around its communal table. It’s the kind of place where special occasions are celebrated, and new traditions quietly take root—an anchor for those seeking the heart of the Hamptons, minus the pretense.

Price Level

$$

Contact

+1 631-604-5765

Reservations Available

Hours

  • Sunday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Monday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Tuesday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Wednesday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Thursday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Friday: 8AM - 11PM
  • Saturday: 8AM - 11PM

Frontier Insights

Hidden Gem
Rare Find
Gem Score
75

Local favorite with excellent reputation

Tourist Awareness

LevelUnknown
Data confidence: high(4 sources)
AI Visibility for Travel Businesses

When Travelers Ask AI, Are You Being Recommended?

ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity are becoming the new travel agents. Track how AI recommends your destination and discover what it takes to get featured.

AI Discovery

See exactly how AI models describe and recommend your business when travelers ask for suggestions

Competitive Edge

Compare your AI visibility against competitors and understand why some businesses get recommended more

Action Plan

Get specific recommendations on how to improve your AI visibility with content and optimization briefs

Free visibility snapshotWeekly trackingChatGPT, Gemini & Perplexity